Skip to content

Rent a journalist: writer, editor, social media & public relations — request a quote

AaronCrowe
Uncategorized

Hold the cilantro, please

Hold the cilantro, please

“Hold the cilantro, please” is how you ask a restaurant to leave the herb off your plate. Plenty of people ask, because for some of us cilantro tastes like soap, and no amount of lime fixes that. It’s also the name of a cooking blog my wife started in 2009.

A new Web site is born in the Crowe family: Hold the cilantro, please is about a cook (my wife, Kristen) who doesn’t like certain ingredients, such as cilantro, and comes up with tasty recipes nonetheless. She promises to update it with her recipes, cooking tips and I might even convince her to add a cooking video or two.

Why some people taste soap

It’s mostly genetics, not pickiness. Researchers have tied the reaction to a cluster of genes that includes OR6A2, a smell receptor that picks up aldehydes. Cilantro leaves contain aldehydes, and so do some soaps. Same chemistry, same unfortunate comparison.

How common is it? Estimates vary by study and by ancestry. As of November 2026, a 23andMe analysis reported roughly 14–21% of people of East Asian, African and European ancestry disliked cilantro, against about 3–7% among South Asian, Hispanic and Middle Eastern respondents. Those are survey numbers, not a medical diagnosis.

Genes don’t explain everything. The common variants account for only a small slice of the difference between people, and exposure matters too. People who grew up eating it tend to like it.

What to use instead of cilantro

There’s no perfect twin. Which swap works depends on the dish:

Swap Best for Note
Flat-leaf parsley Salsa, rice, garnish Use 1:1. Grassy, without the citrus edge.
Parsley and mint, half and half Fresh salsa, salads Keeps the green color and freshness.
Thai basil Cooked dishes, noodles Use 1:1. Stronger, slightly sweet.
Chives Tacos, eggs, soups Milder, onion-like.
Lime juice Anything that needs brightness Add a little at a time. It replaces the zing, not the herb.

Skip dried cilantro. It loses most of its flavor. Ground coriander or a pinch of cumin works better when you want the warm, earthy part of the dish.

How to order without cilantro

  1. Say it when you order, not when the plate arrives.
  2. Ask for it left off the dish, not picked out. Cilantro that has touched the food still flavors it.
  3. Check salsas, guacamole, pho and curry garnishes. They hide it most often.
  4. If the kitchen is blending a sauce, ask whether cilantro goes in.

The blog started because of this exact problem. Cook around the ingredient you can’t stand, and dinner still comes out fine.

FAQ

Why does cilantro taste like soap to me?

Probably because of how your smell receptors detect aldehydes, which are present in both cilantro and some soaps. Genes such as OR6A2 are linked to it, though they explain only part of the story.

Can you learn to like cilantro?

Sometimes. Crushing or chopping the leaves finely breaks down some of the aldehydes, and repeated exposure in small amounts helps some people. Others never warm to it, and that’s fine.

What is the closest substitute for cilantro?

Flat-leaf parsley is the usual pick, ideally with a squeeze of lime. For Thai or Vietnamese dishes, Thai basil or culantro fits better.

Is cilantro the same as coriander?

In the US, cilantro is the fresh leaves and stems, and coriander is the dried seed, ground or whole. In the UK and elsewhere, “coriander” often means the fresh leaf too. People who hate the leaf often like the seed.