Skip to content

Rent a journalist: writer, editor, social media & public relations — request a quote

AaronCrowe
rant

Another journalist not getting paid

Another journalist not getting paid

A photographer billed Al Gore’s Current TV for using his photo without permission, won $588 in small-claims court, and then lost it when the company appealed. That’s the story behind this post, and it’s why I say creators too often go unpaid for work that’s already out in public. If you’re a freelancer or photographer in the same spot, the short version is: put the demand in writing, set a deadline, and know which court or board fits the size of your claim.

From Al Gore’s website

Here’s a photo of Al Gore at work in his office. I took it from his website, and now await his lawsuit.

What happened with Current TV

A story in April 2010 in the New York Times points out how Gore’s cable TV station, Current TV, grabbed a photo off another Web site to use on Current TV. The photo’s owner, an Orinda man, sent Current TV a bill. Instead of paying, Gore’s company sued him in court and won, overturning the photographer’s $588 victory in small-claims court.

Gore and his company must have thought the photo was free because it was already online.

Trade coverage at the time reported the $588 as $500 in damages plus $88 in court costs. It also reported that Current TV argued it had linked to the image on another site rather than copying it. I haven’t seen the court’s full reasoning, so I won’t pretend to explain exactly why the appeal went the company’s way.

The court and Gore have it wrong. People should be paid for their work, and taking a photo from a website and running on your own is illegal. Or should be. I gave credit to Gore’s site by using the photo above, which is what the photographer wanted in the case of Gore stealing his photo. I now wait to see if Gore will follow his own lawyer’s advice and say it’s OK for me to use his website’s photo without paying Gore.

“It was online, so it was free” is wrong

Being visible on a website doesn’t mean a photo or story is licensed for anyone’s use. The creator owns it unless they sold or licensed it. Companies still lift images and text because it’s cheap, and because most creators won’t spend months chasing a few hundred dollars. Businesses that want original material can hire a laid-off journalist instead of borrowing someone else’s work.

That math is the whole problem. The bill is small, the fight is long, and the other side has lawyers on retainer.

What to do when you aren’t paid

This applies whether the unpaid thing is a photo, an article or a ghostwritten blog post.

  1. Check the paperwork. Find the contract, email or invoice that set the rate and due date. No paperwork at all? Write down what was agreed and when, while you still remember.
  2. Send a polite reminder. Late checks are often an accounts-payable slip, not bad faith.
  3. Send a second notice. State the amount, the original due date, and any late fee that is actually in your agreement.
  4. Send a formal demand letter. Give a deadline, say 10 to 14 days, and say you will pursue it if it isn’t met.
  5. Pick your venue. Small claims for modest amounts, a lawyer for larger ones.

Deposits help too. On bigger projects I’d ask for part of the fee up front, and I’d invoice the day the work is delivered.

Where small claims fits, and where it doesn’t

The Current TV case shows the catch. A small-claims win isn’t final, because in California the losing defendant can appeal and get a fresh hearing. A $588 judgment can turn into nothing.

For copyright specifically, the U.S. Copyright Claims Board is a smaller, cheaper alternative to federal court. As of November 2026, based on published summaries of the rules, it caps total recovery at $30,000 per case and $15,000 per work if the work was registered in time. You generally need a copyright registration to file. Check the board’s official rules before you rely on these numbers.

Expect modest awards. In the board’s first final decision in 2023, a photographer asked for the maximum and got $1,000, partly because he couldn’t show what the photo would have fetched as a license. Evidence of your normal licensing fee matters.

Option Best for Watch out for
Demand letter Any unpaid invoice Needs a clear paper trail
Small claims Unpaid fees of a few hundred to a few thousand dollars Dollar limits vary by state, and appeals are possible
Copyright Claims Board Photos or text used without a license Registration needed, awards can be low
Lawyer or federal court Large amounts or repeat infringers Cost can exceed the claim

Laws that help freelancers get paid

New York State’s Freelance Isn’t Free Act, signed in November 2023 and in effect since 2024, requires a written contract for freelance work worth $800 or more, counting contracts over the previous 120 days. If the contract names no payment date, the hiring party must pay within 30 days of completed services. The state attorney general can investigate violations. Other states and cities have their own rules, or none, so look up yours.

This is general information, not legal advice. Whether you can collect depends on your contract, your state and the facts. A short consult with a lawyer is cheap compared with a lost claim.

If you’re a business reading this, one more lesson: pay for what you publish. Hiring someone to write or shoot the material, as I argued in why every company should hire a laid-off journalist, costs far less than a dispute.

FAQ

Can I use a photo I found on a company’s website?

Not without permission or a license. Copyright covers the photo even if it’s free to view online. Look for a stated license, or ask the owner and get the answer in writing.

What did the photographer in the Current TV case win?

He won $588 in small-claims court. Current TV appealed and won, so the award was overturned, as the New York Times reported in April 2010.

How long should I wait before calling an invoice unpaid?

Go by the due date in your agreement. Past it, send a reminder at once. If no date was set, 30 days is a common standard, and it’s the default in New York State’s law.

Can I charge late fees?

Only if they were in your contract or invoice terms before the work. Adding one afterward tends to start a fight without helping you collect.

Is it worth suing over a few hundred dollars?

Sometimes. A firm demand letter usually costs nothing and works more often than people expect. Small claims is cheap to file, but an appeal can undo the win, as it did here.