Skip to content

Rent a journalist: writer, editor, social media & public relations — request a quote

AaronCrowe
Insurance writing

States where you’re most likely to hit a deer with your car

States where you’re most likely to hit a deer with your car

West Virginia, again. State Farm’s latest ranking, based on claims from July 2025 through June 2026, puts the odds of a driver there hitting an animal (mostly deer) at 1 in 46. The national figure is 1 in 145. Montana, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania and Michigan follow.

States where you’re most likely to hit a deer with your car

By Aaron Crowe

Hitting a deer with your car can be scary. It can be especially frightening if you’ve stopped for a deer that’s looking to cross the road.

That’s what happened to Julie Reusch, a communications manager for Allstate Insurance in Pennsylvania, who was pregnant with twins in November 2011 when she stopped on a two-lane road after she saw a curious deer on the side of the road.

A car coming toward her must not have seen the buck stop, hitting it in the 45 mph lane as it went into the oncoming lane, sending the deer into Reusch’s front bumper. No one was injured, though the deer was killed, and Reusch says she was shaken and worried that the deer would crash through the window on her Prius.

“The moment where I saw it happening was very scary,” she says.

Where the deer roam: the top states

I first wrote this piece in 2013, and the numbers have moved a lot since. Here is the current State Farm ranking, built from animal-collision claims filed from July 2025 through June 2026.

Rank State Odds of an animal collision (July 2025–June 2026)
1 West Virginia 1 in 46
2 Montana 1 in 54
3 Wisconsin 1 in 62
4 Pennsylvania 1 in 64
5 Michigan 1 in 68
6 Iowa 1 in 81

Two caveats. State Farm counts all animals, not only deer, though deer make up most of the claims. And the insurer’s list is built on its own policyholders, so another company’s data could shuffle the order a bit. Mississippi, Virginia and Maine also made the top 10, but I did not find their odds, so I left them out.

When deer collisions happen

November is the worst month. State Farm ranks November first, October second and December third for large-animal crashes. Deer are in mating season, they move at dawn and dusk, and the clocks have just changed, so more of your commute happens in the dark.

If you drive a rural road in one of the states above this month, slow down at dusk. Watch the shoulders. And if you see one deer, expect another.

What a deer collision costs

I could not find a 2026 deer-only average published directly by an insurer. Estimates vary by source and year. Recent figures I found run from roughly $4,000 to $5,600 per claim, with the higher end in high-risk regions (MoneyGeek put its high-risk average at $5,620 for 2024). The old $3,305 figure in my original story, from the first half of 2012, is long out of date. Modern cars with sensors and cameras in the bumper cost more to fix.

Your own bill depends on the damage and your deductible.

Type of coverage needed

If you’re involved in a deer collision, the comprehensive part of your car insurance policy — which states don’t mandate that drivers carry — will cover the damage, minus your deductible. Comprehensive covers theft, fire, hail, vandalism and other events out of your control. A claim usually won’t raise your rates unless you have a lot of recent claims, though that varies by insurer and state.

You’d think that hitting a deer would be covered by collision insurance coverage, which normally covers an object or another vehicle hitting your car. Hitting an animal is listed as a loss “other than collision,” so it’s comprehensive coverage that covers it.

The catch: if you swerve and hit a tree or another car to avoid the deer, that can be treated as a collision claim. Without collision coverage, you could pay for the repairs yourself. Braking and holding your lane is usually the safer choice.

After a crash, move to a safe spot, call the police if anyone is hurt or the car is blocking traffic, take photos, and then call your insurer. I cover the claims process more in my latest insurance stories. I also wrote about this topic for the insurer’s website while writing the Allstate blog.

This is general information, not advice for your policy. Check your own deductible and coverage with your insurer or agent.

FAQ

Which state has the most deer collisions?

West Virginia, with odds of 1 in 46 of an animal collision for the July 2025–June 2026 period, according to State Farm. Montana, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania and Michigan are next.

Does car insurance cover hitting a deer?

Yes, if you carry comprehensive coverage. Without it, you pay for the repairs. Liability-only policies do not cover damage to your own car.

Will my rates go up after a deer claim?

Often not, since a deer collision isn’t considered an at-fault accident. Several claims in a short time can change that, and rules differ by state and insurer.

What month are deer collisions most common?

November, followed by October and December, according to State Farm.

Should I swerve to miss a deer?

Generally no. Brake firmly, keep your lane and honk. Swerving can lead to a worse crash, and it may change how the claim is handled.

To read the full story, go to CheapCarInsurance.net, a client of Aaron Crowe, personal finance freelance writer.